Cafe Habana
17 Prince Street (Corner of Prince and Elizabeth Streets)
(212) 625-2002 Reservations Not Accepted
Nolita (short for “North of Little Italy,” absurd, I know) is a small segment of Manhattan that I don’t get to as often as I would like: just a tad too far north of my job, a tad too far south of Matt’s neighborhood, a touch too far east of SoHo. And yet it’s full of great bars, shopping, and, most importantly, food.
Yesterday, in celebration of Matt’s last final of his first year of law school and per my friend, Aline’s, recommendation, Matt, my two coworkers/friends (Mr. and Mrs. Derby), and I traipsed there for lunch at Cafe Habana.
Didn’t I say it was just a tad too far north of my job? Yes, I did, and it is, but with the sun shining and the general pop and buzz in the air that goes along with the idea of one’s last final of the year (Mr. and Mrs. Derby and I are not so old as to forget that incredible feeling) we were willing to make the trip.
The small corner diner has touches of ’50s flare with its curved booths and polished counter, and yet still evokes the idea that you might just be in some breezy spot in Cuba with palm trees painted on the walls. I suppose illegally since US Citizens are technically not allowed to go there.
Disclaimer: AfterTaste (by Sherry) does not condone illegal travel or violations of any US embargoes.
Anyhoo, while the four of us were shoved in the back corner of the joint, we didn’t mind considering the wait was the five minutes that the waitress had promised us.
We shared an order of the grilled Mexican corn (2 ears) loaded with butter, crumbly queso fresco, and lime. It was a salty, cheesy, creamy mess that should not be missed. It is cleverly served with a pile of toothpicks.
I had the grilled steak and corn atop mixed greens and dotted with fried tortilla strips. The greens were tossed in just enough vinaigrette to coat each leaf. Overall, it was a lighter way to enjoy a large hunk of lean, tender steak charred to near perfection during the daylight hours. Next time, however, I will order it without the tortilla strips since chasing little kernels of grilled corn around the plate is time consuming enough without having to figure out how to stab thick, crunchy strips of tortilla.
Matt had the fish tacos, which came with rice and beans. He loved the tacos, which were filling, but not too heavy, as well as the rice and beans, which were far tastier than most.
Dan’s steak sandwich was loaded with peppers and onions and made him want to curl up and take an afternoon siesta…but in a good way. And Jenny’s mango and jicama over mixed greens was refreshing and light. She cleaned her plate of every single leaf.
To top this extravagant lunch off, I had a frozen strawberry margarita served in a classically tall, tapered sundae-style glass. It tasted like the most balanced frozen strawberry lemonade you’ve ever had. Not too syrupy sweet, but not too tart with just a hint of tequila, it was just what I needed as I sat sweating profusely in my gray pant suit surrounded by hipsters in flowy, chambray sundresses with leather bags slung lazily over their shoulders.
Oh yeah, and by “extravagant,” I was referring solely to the somewhat rich, delectable flavors of our meal, not at all to the price, a rarity in such a trendy neighborhood as Nolita.
So go, be prepared to wait a bit, and definitely get the corn.
Lunch Bill (for Four):
- Grilled Mexican Corn - $3.75
- Grilled Steak and Corn Salad - $11.50
- Fish Tacos - $9.95
- Mango and Jicama Salad - $7.50
- Steak Sandwich - $8.95
- 2 Pacifico Beers - $9
- Frozen Strawberry Margarita - $7.95
- Total (not including tax and tip) = $58.60
PS-If you don’t feel like waiting, there’s a take out window right next door to the restaurant. Take your order with you or eat it sitting on one of the benches by the curb.